Workflow

From notice to first draft: bid writing in your AI

Bid writing is turning a buyer's tender documents into a response that scores: every requirement answered, in the order the evaluator marks, with evidence behind each claim. An AI assistant connected to the notice can do the first pass: criteria, compliance matrix, questions for the buyer and a weighted outline. The evidence, the price and every commitment stay with the bid writer. On 19 November 2026 only 9 of 1,026 open Irish notice rows were marked as carrying the selection criteria in the notice. For most bids the first pass therefore starts with the documents.

· 8 min read

The contracting authority shall specify, in the procurement documents, the relative weighting which it gives to each of the criteria chosen to determine the most economically advantageous tender, except where this is identified on the basis of price alone.

Source: eur-lex.europa.eu

On 19 November 2026, 13,596 of 21,636 open German notice rows were marked as carrying the selection criteria in the notice. The figure for Ireland was 9 of 1,026. Where they are missing from the notice, they sit in the tender documents.

A bid is marked against the buyer's own scoring sheet, not against how well it reads. Most of the early work in bid writing is reading. You need to know what the buyer will score, how much each part is worth and what you must prove before your answer is opened. That reading is the part an AI assistant connected to the tender data does fastest.

What does bid writing involve?

Seven steps, in this order, whether one person writes the bid or a team does:

  1. Read the notice and the procurement documents. The notice says what is bought, by when and under which procedure. The documents hold the specification, the selection criteria and the scoring guidance.
  2. Decide whether to bid at all. The bid/no-bid checklist covers that in ten minutes.
  3. Build the compliance matrix. One row per requirement, mandatory or scored, quoted rather than paraphrased, with an owner and a place in the response.
  4. Send clarification questions before the buyer's question deadline, which is earlier than the submission deadline.
  1. Outline the response from the award criteria, in the buyer's order and wording, with a word budget in proportion to the weights.
  2. Write each section with evidence: named projects, numbers, references, CVs.
  3. Price, review and upload, with the final review done by someone who did not write it.

Which parts can an AI assistant draft?

The line falls where the table below puts it. The assistant's column is a first pass for a person to check; the writer keeps the facts.

Part of the bidFirst pass by the assistantStays with the bid writer
Award criteria and weightsRead from the notice when the buyer encoded them, with points or percent statedChecking them against the full documents
Selection criteriaWhich ones apply, and whether a level is publishedWhether you meet the level
Compliance matrixOne row per stated requirement, with source and weightOwners, evidence, status
Clarification questionsGaps and conflicts the documents leave openWhich to send, under whose name
Proposal skeletonHeadings in the buyer's wording, budgets by weightWin themes, claims, the writing
Evidence, price, CVsEmpty slots, marked as neededAll of it
Where the line falls in Victano's bid workflows (response-plan and proposal-skeleton, read 19 November 2026). The assistant's column is a first pass for a person to check.

Where does the first draft come from?

From the award criteria. EU procurement law makes the buyer state the weights. Article 67(5) of Directive 2014/24/EU says the contracting authority:

"shall specify, in the procurement documents, the relative weighting which it gives to each of the criteria chosen to determine the most economically advantageous tender, except where this is identified on the basis of price alone."

Some buyers also put the weights into the notice. Spain's public employment service did for its SAP application development contract, worth EUR 9,090,909.09 and closing on 30 November 2026:

Buyer's criterion (Spanish, as published)Our translationPoints
1.1. Precio ofertadoPrice offered40
2.2. Propuesta de mantenimiento y evolución de aplicaciones sobre SAPProposal for maintaining and evolving the SAP applications40
1.2. Experiencia de los perfiles profesionales por encima de los requisitos mínimosExperience of the proposed staff above the minimum requirements15
2.1.Plan de ejecución y gestión de la demandaDelivery plan and demand management2.5
2.3. Propuesta para abordar las etapas del servicioProposal for handling the stages of the service2.5
Award criteria of TED notice 748198-2026, as Victano read_document returned them on 19 November 2026, sorted by points. The translations are ours.

The tool labels these as "POINTS, not percent: the totals need not sum to 100 and the notice may not say what the maximum is". For the outline, that means the two 40-point criteria get most of the words, and the two 2.5-point plans get a page each, not a chapter. Teams that spend their best week on the interesting section rather than the one worth 40 points lose marks without noticing.

What if the criteria are not in the notice?

Then the first pass has to say so, plainly. The Food Safety Authority of Ireland published a tender for IT software application and development support services, worth EUR 6,500,000 and closing on 22 December 2026. Its notice carries the value, the deadline and the codes. The criteria, in the tool's words, are "in the tender documents", and reading them "needs the pack downloaded".

That is normal. How often the notice carries the criteria depends mostly on the country:

Share of open notice rows marked as carrying the selection criteria in the notice, 19 November 2026

  1. Romania (1,209 of 1,706)70.9%
  2. Germany (13,596 of 21,636)62.8%
  3. Spain (1,653 of 7,740)21.4%
  4. Poland (1,330 of 9,699)13.7%
  5. France (743 of 12,199)6.1%
  6. Ireland (9 of 1,026)0.9%
  7. Lithuania (0 of 1,604)0%
Victano coverage feed, criteria_share (criteria_in_notice of criteria_rows) per country, open rows of every source, read 19 November 2026 at 11:01 UTC. A row counts when its source says the criteria are in the notice; the text can still point to the documents. A notice on TED and on its national portal counts twice.

For an Irish or Lithuanian bid, an assistant that reports no selection criteria from the notice alone is wrong. The criteria exist; they are in the documents. A good first pass names where the documents are and asks you to load them before it builds the matrix.

Which questions should go to the buyer?

The ones the documents leave open, and the ones where the buyer may have gone further than the law allows. The Spanish notice has one of each.

The first is turnover. The buyer coded a minimum yearly turnover requirement but published no figure in the notice. The tool's reading: tell the user the requirement exists and that its size is not published here, and do not estimate it.

The second is the legal cap on that figure. Article 58(3) of the same directive says:

"The minimum yearly turnover that economic operators are required to have shall not exceed two times the estimated contract value, except in duly justified cases such as relating to the special risks attached to the nature of the works, services or supplies."

For this contract the tool computed that cap as EUR 18,181,818.18. A requirement above it is a fair clarification question.

Recorded run · 4tool calls

You

I write bids for a software services company. Find an open IT development tender in Ireland and one where the award criteria are in the notice, and tell me what I can draft before I open the documents.

search_opportunitiesquery "software development and support services", countries IE, status open

1,038 open notices match; first is the Food Safety Authority of Ireland, EUR 6,500,000, closes 22 December 2026, also published on Ireland's eTenders

get_opportunityted:807168-2026

criteria_source in_documents; 23 working days left on 19 November 2026; the eForms XML link holds the buyer's link to the documents

search_opportunitiessame query, status open, criteria_stated true

Spain's public employment service, SAP application development, EUR 9,090,909.09, closes 30 November 2026

read_documentted:748198-2026

five award criteria with points (40, 40, 15, 2.5, 2.5); turnover required, level not published; directive cap EUR 18,181,818.18

Your assistant

For the Spanish tender you can draft the skeleton now: five sections in the buyer's wording, budgeted by points, plus a clarification question on the turnover level.

For the Irish tender you cannot yet. The criteria are in the tender documents, so download the pack from the buyer's link and load it before building the compliance matrix.

Four real calls to mcp.victano.com on a signed-in test account, 19 November 2026 between 11:01 and 11:04 UTC, data as of 04:20 UTC that day. We wrote the question and the answer's wording; every name, sum, date and count is from the tools' output.

What should the assistant never write for you?

Anything the evaluator will treat as a promise or a fact about your company: references, case studies, staff CVs, certifications, prices, service levels. Victano's own skeleton workflow tells the assistant to mark those slots as needed and leave them empty. Its reason: "An invented reference is a disqualification and, in some jurisdictions, a criminal matter."

Treat the assistant's output the way you would treat a junior colleague's first pass: useful structure and a list of gaps. Check every line against the documents before anyone writes into it. It is a reading of public sources, not legal advice.

Do this in your assistant

Paste this

Read https://victano.com/start.md and follow the onboarding instructions. Then open the tender [TED notice number or link], tell me whether the award and selection criteria are in the notice or only in the documents, and draft a proposal skeleton budgeted by the published weights. Leave every reference, CV and price as an empty slot.

Connector address

https://mcp.victano.com/mcp

Search and notice records work without an account. Setup for each assistant is on /install; every source and its last read time is on /coverage.

For finding the notice in the first place, the CPV codes guide shows why one exact code misses most of them. Tender management software vs an MCP compares the two ways of working.

Questions people ask

What does bid writing mean? Writing the response a company submits to a public or private tender: answers to every requirement, in the buyer's order, with evidence and a price. It also carries the forms the procedure asks for.

Can AI write a whole bid? It can draft the structure and the reading: criteria, weights, compliance rows, questions and an outline. It should not write the evidence, the price or any claim about your company that you have not given it.

Finding the criteria and the deadline

Where do I find the award criteria? In the procurement documents: Article 67(5) of Directive 2014/24/EU requires the weights there unless price alone decides. Some buyers also encode them in the notice, and an assistant connected to the notice data can read those directly.

How long before the deadline should bid writing start? As soon as you decide to bid. The clarification deadline comes first, and gathering evidence takes longer than writing, so plan backwards from the submission date in working days.

No sign-up form. Your assistant does the rest.

Say this to Claude Code, Cursor or any assistant that sets itself up, and it connects itself.

Read https://victano.com/start.md and follow the onboarding instructions.